Difference between revisions of "Talk:GWR Pannier 5764"

Latest revision as of 12:45, 7 January 2017

This article gives the 5700 as a 4FThe British Railways system of classifying steam locomotives by power using a number from 0, least powerful, to 9, most powerful, followed by either F for freight, P for Passenger or MT for Mixed Traffic.. So does Scottish Steam: A Celebration By Keith Langston https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=mPNsBQAAQBAJ&lpg=PT337&ots=b3UyIbOWvR&dq=5700%20AND%204F&pg=PT337#v=onepage&q=5700%20AND%204F&f=false. However, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_locomotives_of_British_Railways and my Ian Allen give it as 3FThe British Railways system of classifying steam locomotives by power using a number from 0, least powerful, to 9, most powerful, followed by either F for freight, P for Passenger or MT for Mixed Traffic., and the 9400 as 4FThe British Railways system of classifying steam locomotives by power using a number from 0, least powerful, to 9, most powerful, followed by either F for freight, P for Passenger or MT for Mixed Traffic.. I'm sure I read somewhere the power classification had been wrongly published and the error had been perpetuated. Can anyone comment authoritatively, and reference it (and the error) in the article please? Thanks --Patrick Hearn (talk) 14:24, 29 December 2016 (UTC)

I suspect I got 4FThe British Railways system of classifying steam locomotives by power using a number from 0, least powerful, to 9, most powerful, followed by either F for freight, P for Passenger or MT for Mixed Traffic. for the original article from the Bookazine "British Steam Preserved", whose author was Keith Langston as above. Classic British Steam Locomotives (ISBN 1-86147-138-6) also goes with 3FThe British Railways system of classifying steam locomotives by power using a number from 0, least powerful, to 9, most powerful, followed by either F for freight, P for Passenger or MT for Mixed Traffic. in line with Wikipedia / Ian Allen. I'd be happy to change it to 3FThe British Railways system of classifying steam locomotives by power using a number from 0, least powerful, to 9, most powerful, followed by either F for freight, P for Passenger or MT for Mixed Traffic. as being the more likely, pending definitive information.--Robin (talk) 15:48, 29 December 2016 (UTC)

I have changed it, referencing both. Thanks--Patrick Hearn (talk) 19:12, 29 December 2016 (UTC)

I have now found some definitive information, courtesy of Michael Clemens website. The document Midlands Division (Ex WR) & Gloucester District - Locomotive Route Availability (Branch Lines)- June 1963 confirms that BRBritish Rail or British Railways(W) rated the 57xxA GWR 5700 Class 0-6-0PT engine as 4FThe British Railways system of classifying steam locomotives by power using a number from 0, least powerful, to 9, most powerful, followed by either F for freight, P for Passenger or MT for Mixed Traffic.. I will update the article accordingly.